Here's what I would give:
Lun: A break. He must work pretty hard to keep us from turning into rabid dogs while waiting for the next episode. (maybe the ownership of the universe too.)
Fitz: Inspiration. I wan't some more Crestfallen comics.
Strayed: A home. You have wandered enough soldier.
Porter: Prince hit by a powerful bar of Balefire, therefore undoing all the damage he has done the last week or so.
Teen: I dunno... puberty?

Just play'n Teen.
Reapergal: Meh, a dildo, why not.
Impossible: I think Strayed spoke for us all.
Tele: Something weird yet cool, I havn't decided but maybe a trip to Australia or a blow up Rhue.
Sage: $100, he's wise enough to know what he really wants.
War: a 3rd grade English course.
CJ: An RPG better than Chrono Trigger, I know he'd love it.
Jera: ...I really don't know, maybe a switch or a cane, modelled to look like a shadow sword of course.
I get the feeling I've missed a lot of people I shouldn't have, So as a gift to the whole of Crestfallen I'd give a mod for 'The Way' which turns all of the character sprites into crestfallen look-alikes.
Well it's 2:45am on 25th of December in Brisbane, Australia. So MERRY CHRISTMAS. I might not be on later today and I'm going away for 2 weeks later today so I won't see you guys in a while. (yeah yeah, I'm not gone yet, no jumping for joy.)..and I guess I'll miss the release of episode 6 too... fuckshit.
So I just wanted to say that despite our ups and downs, I've really enjoyed being part of 'The Way' community this year, and I hope it'll be as much fun next year.
MERRY CHRISTMAS AND A HAPPY NEW YEAR!
Sincerely, Josh Jones.