The only thing that makes American Dad remotely watchable is the effeminate alien and the German skier fish. And neither one of those is that good. So the show basically sucks.
I own seasons 1 and 2 of Family Guy on DVD, my girlfiend has season 3. Either you're sitting there blankly or laughing your ass off. Pretty hit or miss, but definitely good.
I liked the few episodes of Futurama I saw. Definitely a bit edgier and funnier than the Simpsons, and Bender is just hilarious.
But you still gotta give almighty props to the Simpsons. Without the success of that show, none of the rest of would exist. Sure, it's repetitive now - after this many years it has to be - but in its prime it's fucking great.
And I had to laugh when in a recent episode of the Simpsons, somebody opens up a dictionary to the word "Plagiarism" and there's a picture of Family Guy's Peter Griffin. Right below that is a definition of "Plagiarism of Plagiarism" with a picture of American Dad.
