Sage Of The Wise wrote:Dirk seems unlikely since when Dirk relises who Scatha was he really didn't take it as such a big deal. You'd think one of them would act a little more emotional towards the other.(and the fact that Dirk looks to be 300 years older then her) Strata on the other hand could be the one. We all know Strat's always looking for the best girl and if he was with Scatha in the past after she got burned he'd be sure to find a new girl once he got a look at her. This would explain Scathas hatred to men. Also Slade knows Strata from somewhere but doesn't remember where, it could be very likely that he remembers him being Scatha's lover before she was burned.
I don't think Dirk is so unlikely. He is evidently older than Scatha, but it's tough to say by how much. Our only way of estimating Scatha's age is indirect, based on her brother's apparent age. I would say that Slade looks significantly older that Rhue, Strata, Traziun, or any of the other major characters whose face we've seen, except Dirk himself. Moreover, I don't recall anything that would suggest that Chasta wasn't older than Slade. Ultimately, Dirk could be a mere ten years older than Scatha, but even a much larger age differential wouldn't invalidate them as potential lovers.
Their behavior towards each other also seems to me perfectly consistent with this theory. They are obviously fond of one-another, but given that it's been at least a decade since their ill-fated tryst, I wouldn't expect that much more. For Dirk, it might not have been a big deal, just another conquest in his long life of womanizing. Scatha, for whom it certainly was a big deal, has chosen to disassociate herself from her earlier identity as Chasta. She doens't want to become emotionally entangled with her old, painful life, so she sublimates her response to Dirk's reappearance into other channels.