Carl Jung is a douche.
I don't want to name names, (cough) that arogant jackass who totaly misinterpreted my beautiful creation (cough) but I feel I need to set some things straight.
Jesus, this hurts me to even have to reply to such an obviously idiotic reply, and it goes against my gut. Usually to acknowledge ignorance is to encourage it, but I'm left with no choice but to confront someone with such an obvious and ridiculous misinterpretation, before they get other a row of morons lining up behind them.
While I am well versed in "Star Wars" and "Lain" I have yet to see anything anywhere that can adequately convince me that Jung was anything other than a delusional douche. Perhaps the time he spent under the tutelage of Eugene Bleuler made him a little bit wrong in the head. Jung is perhaps the west's most embarassing collection of foolish, speculatory, non-empirical, and down right ludicrous notions of phsycological, and philisophical thought.
So why don't we start with the tenant that the majority of Jungians seem to hold most dear: The collective unconscious. It has no media that can transmit or interpret it, it's just there. Like a big magic ghost floating around, "WHOO WHOO WHOO I'M THE COLLECTIVE UNCONSCIOUS! I WILL LET INFANT CHILDREN THE WORLD OVER COMPREHEND THE GREATEST MYSTERIES OF EXISTENCE!"
Alright alirght, I get it how you and many other nitwits could mistake the "Phantom Slasher" for "The Shadow" and certain other characters for certain archetypes, Lyra sure does seem a hell of a lot like an anima, and traziun makes a fine "Old Man." If we wanna make Rhue a hermie we can throw all sorts of animuses in there too, but would anybody with half a brain really wanna do that?
And while you talk a good game about transparent allegories I find that if a work of art is impossible to comprehend their is no reason to create it at all. It's not like your frickin' magic collective unconscious is gonna fly right up to some nimrods ear and say:
"WOOO WOOO WOOO I'M THE COLLECTIVE UNCONSCIOUS! BECAUSE YOU ARE STUPID AND CANNOT UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE PLAYING I WILL LET YOU IN ON A LITTLE SECRET."
The Jung ass-licking moron who incited me to this is prime proof that we live in a world of morons, and thus we must be ever more vigorous in adhearing only to what we can observe and repeat, not dumb garbage that comes to us from nowhere.
If we start believing every retarded notion that comes into our head believing it to be a whisper from the voice of God we are surely going to embarass ourselves.
For all the talk of ur-plays and archetypes I think it is good to remember that Jung "rejoined the collective unconscious" long ago, way before people realized that meta-physics is garbage.
Jesus, this hurts me to even have to reply to such an obviously idiotic reply, and it goes against my gut. Usually to acknowledge ignorance is to encourage it, but I'm left with no choice but to confront someone with such an obvious and ridiculous misinterpretation, before they get other a row of morons lining up behind them.
While I am well versed in "Star Wars" and "Lain" I have yet to see anything anywhere that can adequately convince me that Jung was anything other than a delusional douche. Perhaps the time he spent under the tutelage of Eugene Bleuler made him a little bit wrong in the head. Jung is perhaps the west's most embarassing collection of foolish, speculatory, non-empirical, and down right ludicrous notions of phsycological, and philisophical thought.
So why don't we start with the tenant that the majority of Jungians seem to hold most dear: The collective unconscious. It has no media that can transmit or interpret it, it's just there. Like a big magic ghost floating around, "WHOO WHOO WHOO I'M THE COLLECTIVE UNCONSCIOUS! I WILL LET INFANT CHILDREN THE WORLD OVER COMPREHEND THE GREATEST MYSTERIES OF EXISTENCE!"
Alright alirght, I get it how you and many other nitwits could mistake the "Phantom Slasher" for "The Shadow" and certain other characters for certain archetypes, Lyra sure does seem a hell of a lot like an anima, and traziun makes a fine "Old Man." If we wanna make Rhue a hermie we can throw all sorts of animuses in there too, but would anybody with half a brain really wanna do that?
And while you talk a good game about transparent allegories I find that if a work of art is impossible to comprehend their is no reason to create it at all. It's not like your frickin' magic collective unconscious is gonna fly right up to some nimrods ear and say:
"WOOO WOOO WOOO I'M THE COLLECTIVE UNCONSCIOUS! BECAUSE YOU ARE STUPID AND CANNOT UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE PLAYING I WILL LET YOU IN ON A LITTLE SECRET."
The Jung ass-licking moron who incited me to this is prime proof that we live in a world of morons, and thus we must be ever more vigorous in adhearing only to what we can observe and repeat, not dumb garbage that comes to us from nowhere.
If we start believing every retarded notion that comes into our head believing it to be a whisper from the voice of God we are surely going to embarass ourselves.
For all the talk of ur-plays and archetypes I think it is good to remember that Jung "rejoined the collective unconscious" long ago, way before people realized that meta-physics is garbage.