Crestfallen Studios

by **The Fly** » Mon Oct 04, 2004 10:56 am

I reckon with REquims view. does anyone see any flaws with it though?

by **Flibbo** » Mon Oct 04, 2004 1:37 pm

ok here are my hopeless theorys please tell me if i am wrong, i like helpful critisism
it is ordered into characters

RHUE
why are we so sure that Rhue's alter ego is the PS?
i think it is also possible (if not more likly) that Rhue is the PS's alter ego or that rhue died in the landorin massacre and the PS absorbed his aura.

RHUE'S SWORD
His sword, If its a shadow sword why can he also use the illuminati sword aura? Could the "sword aura" system be a clue that it isn't rhue but in fact his sword that absorbs auras?

GAIUS
Gaius could also be the PS because his faceset is similar but more than this has he ever been seen with the PS? Perhaps he is just after rhue's sword in episode 5 telling him that he is the PS.

TRAZIUN
Traziun being the PS? i find this very unlikly as we have no evidance to point to this idea. i DO think that he will be going after the PS in 6 for killing his mother though.

KLOE
We are starting to see a very dark streak in her of late, killing Foreman Baller, a mysterious history with Gaius and being convenently absent during any slasher attacks.

STRATA
too disturbed by the death of Lyrra to be him, plus he is evil and therefore too obvious. plus, no evidance.

SCATHA
Unlikly, much more of a candidate for Serena but im having doubts about that theory too as she is Slade's sister.

SERENA
until we know more about who she is (if we've met her yet) we can't be sure but it is a good possibility. She must of been traumatized as a child due to the Landorin Massacre.

LYRRA
is a possibility, traumatized by landorin and her whereabouts are unclear during all the sightings. when she hit rhue in 4 and knocked him into the water she showed alot of strength but i may be overanalyzing that.

KYGAR
dead before the latest attack but maybe rhue absorbed his aura and did the last one himself? this would also support Gaius saying that rhue is the PS at the end because at that time he would be technically telling the truth but i still don't think so. i expect to find out more about what happend to kygar before he came and took the plunge with rhue in 5 though

MEDIAN
two ideas about this one
1) i don't think so because he is in the dream estrana which i think is actually the afterlife since Jed is in there. another theory for the dream estrana is that he Rhue absorbs the auras of EVERYONE he kills like Jed and (shock) median?!?!?!? putting them in a dream estrana. He could of killed median if he is the phantom slasher or something.

and

2) yes he is, he's aware of it and is probably damn proud but (al la my first theory) absorbed rhue's aura after the landorin massacre which is why that headhunter thought it was median, it was.

LEXUS
No way, sorry but i refuse this theory.

LYRRA'S BROTHER
hmmm, this is an interesting one as we know so little about him. one idea I have is that her brother is in fact rhue. Both at landorin after all. or maybe Median?

UNKNOWN CHARACTER
probably not but its the most workable theory

DIPPY
oh COME ON

my favorite theory is the first one about rhue being the PS's alter ego, not the other way around

on a completly unrelated topic, how sure are we that rhue actually exist? Who's heard of him? Who has ANY knowledge of him except him? maybe rhue is from (i dunno) Xor or someplace and he absorbed the aura of someone else who DID experiance that (perhaps Median?) but changed some details to make it fit like his name.

mind you i think Trazuin has a chance of being serena so don't take me too seriously

by **The Fly** » Mon Oct 04, 2004 1:59 pm

Serena can't be Scatha / Chasta as Scatha / Chasta has definatly blond hair whilst you can change the colour hair of serena depending on THAT choice. of course it could have been dyed.

by **Flibbo** » Mon Oct 04, 2004 2:10 pm

thats why i said im having doubts about her.
plus i think that choice is unrelated to the story, one of my fave theories is that he isnt actually in love with her or cant remember her as well as he thinks. that hes just using her memory to keep him going.

i mean whats gonna happen when he finds her? go away a live happily ever after? i think not

but i agree its probably not scatha

by **The Fly** » Mon Oct 04, 2004 2:13 pm

gd point. Rhue has spent practically all his life searching fo r serena. what happens when she is found, if she is.

by **Flibbo** » Mon Oct 04, 2004 2:24 pm

he'll probably realise he doesn't actually love her and go on a killing spree or commit suicide or summit

by **Sage Of The Wise** » Mon Oct 04, 2004 7:53 pm

I think Rhue isn't the phantom slasher, but he'll go on for a episode or two thinking he is.

BTW its Midian, not Median.

by **lheomane** » Mon Oct 04, 2004 9:38 pm

Btw about lexus being dead who else saw her when rhue went to visit cesta in her cell?

by **Flibbo** » Tue Oct 05, 2004 9:51 am

yeah but wasn't she translusent? like rhue in dream estrana

Edit: i just thought, could it be that rhue still hasn't woken up? probably not, its a bit farfetched

by **DSOK** » Tue Oct 05, 2004 11:03 am

Flibbo wrote:yeah but wasn't she translusent? like rhue in dream estrana

Edit: i just thought, could it be that rhue still hasn't woken up? probably not, its a bit farfetched

I don't think "Rhue" was ever unconscious. His consciousness was simply not associated with his body, because his sword had ben taken away.

by **Flibbo** » Tue Oct 05, 2004 11:45 am

but he's been away from his sword before and not gone to a dream world

like when he makes slade come with him to get his sword and he finds it in that guy's head

by **Fredric** » Tue Oct 05, 2004 1:09 pm

In his head...
Is there any other time Rhue has been without the sword?

By the way, Lun removed sword throwing becaude he said it was too advanced right? :wink:

by **DSOK** » Tue Oct 05, 2004 1:57 pm

Flibbo wrote:but he's been away from his sword before and not gone to a dream world

like when he makes slade come with him to get his sword and he finds it in that guy's head

Yeah, and that's the only time. I suggest that whatever aura/consciousness was native to his body was lost in Jopaga's lab. See this thread for my full exposition.

by **Flibbo** » Tue Oct 05, 2004 2:28 pm

interesting idea to be sure yes.

DAMN YOU LUN, MY BRAIN HURTS NOW.

too many theories

by **Johnny(TM)** » Thu Oct 28, 2004 5:59 pm

Okay, the Episode 5 finished as Rhue is the Phantom Slasher, but I saw him earlier with Rhue on the same map in Episode 1 and Episode 2. I guess it's Gaius, just look at his face.
What do you think?

OFF: How can Lexus survive Episode 4? She was one of my fav char.

Crestfallen Studios

The PS, Who could it be?

Who is online